OBJECTIVE OF I SHOULD HAVE KNOWN THAT: Score points by correctly answering the trivia questions of things you should know.
NUMBER OF PLAYERS: 2+ players
MATERIALS OF I SHOULD HAVE KNOWN THAT: 110 cards
TYPE OF GAME: Board game
AUDIENCE: 14+
OVERVIEW OF I SHOULD HAVE KNOWN THAT
Want to test your general knowledge? There’s no better way to do that in a fun and entertaining way than by playing some good old trivia. While preparing questions for a trivia night can take some time and effort, you can make it a lot easier with I Should Have Known That. This board game contains 110 cards with 400+ questions about things you should already know. But, of course, rather than your standard trivia game, I Should Have Known That has a bit of a twist to it that makes the game that much more fun!
So, here are the rules for I Should Have Known That so that you can play this super fun game with your friends and family.
Just so you know, we’ve included affiliate links in this post – clicking on them supports us without any extra cost to you!
- Age: 14+ / Players 2+
- Package Dimensions : 6" L x 6" W x 2" H
- Country of origin : Poland
SETUP FOR I SHOULD HAVE KNOWN THAT
Before you begin, decide whether you want to play individually or in teams. If playing in teams, keep the teams small – max 3 people per team. Choose one player to be the score keeper as well. But don’t worry; they’ll be able to play the game as well.
HOW TO PLAY I SHOULD HAVE KNOWN THAT
Here is how to play I Should Have Known That, the fun trivia game.
First things first, keep in mind, everyone starts at 0 points.
THE FIRST QUESTION
The scorekeeper starts the game by taking a card and asking the player or team on their left the top question on the card. That player must either answer the question or skip. If they skip, that player’s turn is over. They do not lose any points for skipping their turn.
THE SECOND QUESTION
When skipping turns, the scorekeeper must ask the next player the second question on the card. Again, this player has a choice to answer the question or skip their turn.
And so on.
A CORRECT ANSWER
Now, if a player decides to answer the question and answers it correctly, the scorekeeper lets them know that it was correct. They do not gain or lose any points.
AN INCORRECT ANSWER
However, if a player decides to answer the question and answers it incorrectly, the scorekeeper turns the card to see how many points they lose. Mark these points down somewhere to keep track of the points.
ADDITIONAL RULES
Now, the above rules are all that are written on the I Should Have Known That box, but this obviously comes with a massive flaw: you could technically skip every question and still come up on top, as you only get a penalty for an incorrect answer. This does not properly incentivize players.
So, here are a couple of I Should Have Known That rule variations to make the game more competitive and playable:
- If you get a correct answer, you can penalize another player of your choice with the negative points you would have gotten for an incorrect answer.
- You cannot skip more than three questions in a game.
END OF GAME
Whoever has the score closest to 0 at the end of the game wins!
FAQ
Is “I Should Have Known That” a Good Game?
Yes, I Should Have Known That is a super fun game that you can play with friends and family to test your general knowledge in a game format.
How Many People Can Play “I Should Have Known That” Game?
You can play I Should Have Known That with 2 or more players. There’s no official cap to how many people can play. If the group is particularly large, divide everyone into teams of 2 or 3 people.
- 20 Card Games for Two with a Standard Deck of Cards - December 21, 2025
- 50 Must-Have Board Games in Your Collection - December 7, 2025
- 20 Fun Minute to Win It Thanksgiving Games - November 10, 2025